A Kaleidoscope of Love: Artistry’s Sweet Charity Pays Tribute to Resilience and Heart

Shinah Hey and Brendon Nelson Finn, Photo by Dan Norman Photography

Artistry’s production of Sweet Charity at the Bloomington Schneider Theater is a mix of color, comedy, and heartfelt perseverance. With its blend of visual storytelling, spirited performances, and live orchestral charm, this rendition of the 1960s classic hits all the right notes—and then some.

The story follows the adventures of Charity Hope Valentine, a dance hall hostess with a heart full of love and a knack for falling for the wrong men. Despite her bad luck and the world’s often cruel treatment, Charity is a hopeless romantic who dreams of escape—a regular job, a family, and a life far from her own. Her journey is marked by encounters with colorful characters, from movie star Vittorio Vidal to the reserved and panicky Oscar Lindquist. Through it all, Charity remains a loveable and resilient hero who never stops getting back up, no matter how many times life throws her into the metaphorical (or literal) river.

From the first downbeat of the overture, conducted by none other than Anita Ruth, the production sets a high bar. Ruth, returning triumphantly to Artistry, leads a 20-person orchestra with music director Isabella Dawis, bringing Cy Coleman’s catchy score to life. The opening moments, introducing the orchestra onstage, emphasize the vibrant energy they provide throughout the evening. Truly, without this live pit, Sweet Charity wouldn’t feel half as alive.

Laura Leffler’s direction breathes fresh life into this 1969 story. Leffler balances the musical’s comedic charm with its darker undertone, crafting a story that’s as much about perseverance as it is about love. Her nuanced approach brings Charity’s struggles to light, making her journey both heartfelt and relatable.

The scenic and lighting design adds a distinct flavor to this production. Each scene is given a specific color, with the cyc, props, and accessories reflecting the hue defining the location. The Fandango Ballroom comes alive in purple, while the park is blue. The decision to dress all characters in black, except for Charity’s signature red dress, is a cool visual choice. It allows the colorful accessories donned by the cast—from purple gloves to white scarves—to pop, seamlessly tying each scene’s palette together.

The lighting, designed by Shannon Elliot with assited by Kyia Britts, is visually striking. A visual symphony of color and emotion, the lighting design is simply mesmerizing. From perfectly timed cues to bold transitions, the lighting becomes its own character, guiding the audience’s emotions and grounding them in the story. Stage Manager Sam Smith’s timing ensures every lighting shift syncs flawlessly with the choreography and music, making each moment satisfyingly sharp.

A delightful nod to the 1969 film, the use of projections brings a playful, fourth-wall-breaking element to the show. The clever use of projections adds a charming cinematic touch to the stage.A hanging projector displays text titles that provide scene-setting commentary, much like the movie. This clever integration not only pays homage to the film but also elevates the stage experience, starting with Charity herself acknowledging the titles with endearing excitement.

Shinah Hey shines—both figuratively and literally—as Charity Hope Valentine. Shinah Hey is luminous, delivering a performance that’s equal parts charm and depth. Her portrayal captures Charity’s cheerful optimism while hinting at the heartache hidden underneath. Hey channels Shirley MacLaine’s iconic take on the role but makes it her own, infusing Charity with boundless energy and a vulnerability that’s impossible to ignore. In her bright red dress, she commands attention and draws the audience’s empathy, making Hey shine all the more brighter. 

Brendon Nelson Finn delivers a standout performance as Oscar Lindquist, Brendon Nelson Finn’s portrayal of Oscar is both hilarious and heartwarming. Charity’s quirky love interest. With his humor, charm, and a voice that soars in numbers like “I’m the Bravest Individual” and “Sweet Charity,” Finn is both relatable and endearing.

Jaclyn McDonald and Hope Nordquist bring warmth and wit to the roles of Nickie and Helene, Charity’s loyal friends. Their duets, particularly “There’s Gotta Be Something Better Than This,” showcase their vocal talent and the poignant dreams their characters hold.

Adán Varela is captivating as Vittorio Vidal, the dashing movie star who briefly sweeps Charity off her feet. Adán Varela’s vocal prowess is nothing short of breathtaking. His operatic vocals in “Too Many Tomorrows” are breathtaking, leaving the audience in awe. Varela’s versatility shines as he transitions into the role of Herman, the Fandango Ballroom’s gruff yet lovable manager.

Artistry’s Sweet Charity is a testament to the power of collaboration and creativity. A production that dazzles with its artistry and heart. With its vibrant design, talented cast, and impeccable direction, the production brings a timeless story to life in a way that still feels fresh and innovative. Whether you’re a die-hard fan of the musical or new to Charity’s tale, this production will leave you cheering for her—and her unbreakable spirit.

As Charity herself might say, the “fickle finger of fate” has pointed squarely at success for this production. Don’t miss your chance to experience it and get your tickets today. Now through February 16th.

Artistry has some great offers that create accessibility for students, veterans, educators and more. Read all about them here!

Here are two I’ve been doing for as long as I can remember.

Pay What You Can Night: Monday February 3rd, get in line early for tickets as little as a dollar, and for as much as you can pay. ($48 ticket value)

Student Rush $25 Tickets: Available at the Ticket Office starting 60 minutes prior to any performance. Bring your ID and show up early, then check out the Inez Greenburg and Atrium Art Galleries in your spare time!

Bonus Opportunity!

Ushering: Artistry is a great place to volunteer in a variety of an opportunities. You get to meet some amazing patrons, experience the theater scene from a different perspective, not to mention watch the show for free! LINK HERE